Current:Home > MyExxon Climate Fraud Investigation Widens Over Missing ‘Wayne Tracker’ Emails -Ascend Finance Compass
Exxon Climate Fraud Investigation Widens Over Missing ‘Wayne Tracker’ Emails
View
Date:2025-04-26 09:08:20
The probe of ExxonMobil by the New York Attorney General’s Office is widening. Investigators have taken depositions of company executives and issued additional subpoenas to determine whether the company may have destroyed evidence connected to an alias email used by former Exxon CEO Rex Tillerson.
The disclosure was made Friday in arguments filed by New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman in a Manhattan federal court. He is seeking dismissal of a request by Exxon for an injunction that would halt his investigation into the oil giant involving whether it misled shareholders and the public about the risks of climate change.
Attorneys for Schneiderman did not elaborate in the 25-page document on the scope of the expanded investigation other than to suggest that it involved the recent disclosure that Tillerson, now U.S. secretary of state, used an email alias when discussing issues including climate change and the risk that it posed to the company.
New York and Massachusetts investigators denounced the company’s attempt in federal court to derail their parallel inquiries as a vexatious legal tactic that has no chance of succeeding.
“So far, this federal action’s primary purpose has been to investigate the NYOAG’s Investigation,” the New York brief states.
The filings by Schneiderman and Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey represent the first round in a series of legal jousts expected over the course of the summer before U.S. District Court Judge Valerie Caproni.
The two attorneys general argued that the proper venue for Exxon to fight the investigations, which are based on each state’s fraud statutes, are in the respective state courts. Having a federal court intervene could mean that states might lose their autonomy in future investigations. “If this action proceeds, even to discovery, federal judges regularly could be called upon to determine when a recipient of a document subpoena may learn details of, or even halt, the state investigation that generated the subpoena,” according to the New York brief.
Healey’s office echoed that position in its brief.
The disclosure by Schneiderman’s office of a widening investigation focused on the possible destruction of evidence that heightened the stakes.
“In this ongoing investigation, the NYOAG has served additional subpoenas upon Exxon,” according to the New York brief. “For example, because of concern about spoliation of documents, and in conformance with proceedings before the New York court on that issue, the NYOAG has taken, pursuant to subpoena, testimony of witnesses who may possess information relevant to spoliation.”
The expanded investigation comes after Exxon conceded that it failed to preserve all documents from Tillerson’s shadow email account, under the alias Wayne Tracker, and has failed to turn over other documents from top executives. New York investigators said in the brief that “no preservation hold was placed on Wayne Tracker” emails by Exxon, a process meant to insure they were not destroyed.
“We have and will continue to use all of the tools at our disposal to get to the bottom of these issues and to further our investigation,” said Amy Spitalnick, Schneiderman’s press secretary.
An Exxon spokesman did not respond to a request for comment. Exxon has until June 16 to formally respond in court.
Schneiderman’s office disclosed the existence of Tillerson’s alternate email as part of an open investigation of Exxon that began in November 2015 in connection with possible securities fraud over whether the company misled shareholders and the public about climate change.
Tillerson used the Wayne Tracker email account for eight years to discuss, among other things, climate change-related issues and the risks they posed to the company’s business, investigators claim.
The company turned over a handful of the emails in January and at that time said the emails had been overlooked because the company did not have the technical capability to identify them.
Exxon later said it could account for all but a one-month period of emails from Tillerson’s alternate email account, from September to November 2014, according to a letter to a New York state court judge.
The case landed in Caproni’s courtroom in March after a federal judge in Texas determined Exxon’s challenge to the investigations was best settled in New York.
While Exxon enjoyed a series of favorable rulings in Texas, Caproni has signaled she is skeptical of Exxon’s arguments to put a stop to climate fraud investigations by the attorneys general of New York and Massachusetts.
Investigations launched by the two attorneys general provoked Exxon to file a lawsuit seeking an injunction to derail the probes. The investigations focus on whether past statements by Exxon questioning climate change science and downplaying climate change risks to the company constituted a form of fraud against the public and its shareholders.
Exxon argued that the investigations were politically motivated and intended to silence the company and any others who did not share the same views of climate change as the two attorneys general. The company has indicated that it will repeat that argument in Caproni’s court.
veryGood! (4)
Related
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Sunisa Lee’s long road back to the Olympics ended in a familiar spot: the medal stand
- Jailer agrees to plead guilty in case of inmate who froze to death at jail
- Transit officials say taxi driver drove onto tracks as train was approaching and was killed
- See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
- Massachusetts lawmaker pass -- and pass on -- flurry of bills in final hours of formal session
- 14-month-old boy rescued after falling down narrow pipe in the yard of his Kansas home
- Transit officials say taxi driver drove onto tracks as train was approaching and was killed
- Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
- 16-year-old brother fatally shot months after US airman Roger Fortson was killed by deputy
Ranking
- IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
- 'Just glad to be alive': Woman rescued after getting stuck in canyon crevice for over 13 hours
- Illinois sheriff whose deputy shot Sonya Massey says it will take rest of his career to regain trust
- Carrie Underwood will return to ‘American Idol’ as its newest judge
- Could your smelly farts help science?
- Jonathan Majors breaks silence on Robert Downey Jr. replacing him as next 'Avengers' villain
- Dwyane Wade's Olympic broadcasts showing he could be future of NBC hoops
- Court reverses conviction against former NH police chief accused of misconduct in phone call
Recommendation
Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
Woman faces life in prison for killing pregnant woman to claim her unborn child
Pennsylvania’s long-running dispute over dates on mail-in voting ballots is back in the courts
NBC defends performances of Peyton Manning, Kelly Clarkson on opening ceremony
Gen. Mark Milley's security detail and security clearance revoked, Pentagon says
Alabama woman pleads guilty to defrauding pandemic relief fund out of $2 million
Paris Olympics: Simone Biles, Team USA gymnastics draw record numbers for NBC
Olympic boxer at center of gender eligibility controversy wins bizarre first bout